data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/b88dc/b88dcc9b3eefe7210d1a57f6027ad06ff9d16677" alt="Lord of the rings the battle for middle earth 2 iso"
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/5620f/5620f327bd115ffa646c171202fbfb87f2d60028" alt="lord of the rings the battle for middle earth 2 iso lord of the rings the battle for middle earth 2 iso"
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/f754c/f754ce6361887abccf60f84e47b7323407a7c52c" alt="lord of the rings the battle for middle earth 2 iso lord of the rings the battle for middle earth 2 iso"
The designers commendably do away with peon convoys by having a single lump resource type —called, aptly, “resources†— and by providing a limited number of real estate “lots†on which to place your structures. As in the Kohan series, infantry and archers are created in squads of five or ten, although bigger fun-bets like heroes, mountain trolls, and Nazgul arrive in sets of one. It “simplifies†the usual real-time strategy gameplay—removing or dressing down tactical options, unit types, depth, or any semblance of linear narrative— and becomes a repetitive grind.įour playable factions are available: Gondor and Rohan for the Good side, with Saruman’s Isengard and Sauron’s Mordor answering the cattle-call for Evil. It effortlessly trumps War of the Ring like a Nazgul but can’t hold a candle to meatier fare like Dawn of War. But the films were exhilarating all the same, while the game falls short.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/6c6ef/6c6ef871f8b2339737951e38e29ea5c7dd273922" alt="lord of the rings the battle for middle earth 2 iso lord of the rings the battle for middle earth 2 iso"
Just as Peter Jackson’s spectacular Lord of the Rings movie trilogy evoked awe for its masterful visual presentation, the terrific-looking Battle for Middle-Earth likewise manages to impress through graphics rather than substance.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/b88dc/b88dcc9b3eefe7210d1a57f6027ad06ff9d16677" alt="Lord of the rings the battle for middle earth 2 iso"